N. Raghu Babu Environmental Engineer, Central Pollution Control Board, Parivesh Bhawan,
East Arjun Nagar, Delhi - 110 032
Anand Kumar Asst.
Environmental Engineer Central Pollution Control Board, Parivesh
Bhawan, East Arjun Nagar, Delhi -
110032
Introduction India is passing through a phase
of rapid industrialisation and development. In the process of development, the
issues confronting are to achieve desired socio-economic development on one hand
and safeguarding of the environment and maintaining good quality living
conditions on the other. Each developmental activity includes a land use. The
environmentally relevant land uses that can pose impact on the environment
include trade, industry, housing, surface transport, refuse/haz. waste and
wastewater treatment installations, quarrying/mining, agriculture, recreation
and tourism etc.
Of various developmental activities, the industrial
activity has the potential to cause irreversible reactions in the environment
and hence is posing a major threat. In case of industrial development,
environmental impact assessment (EIA) has been conventionally used as a tool for
permitting new projects. The inadequacies in the current procedures of
environmental impact assessment and industrialisation include:
The targets for industrial development are fixed but the sites for these
industries to come up are rarely pre-determined thereby paving the way for
haphazard siting of industries.
The responsibility of selecting a site is primarily entrusted with the
entrepreneurs and this does not necessarily lead to objective assessment of
environmental aspects.
The information base available for evaluating environmental impacts and
taking decisions on industrial siting is weak. Hence, it causes subjectivity in
decision- making process as well as lack of transparency and delay.
Spatial planning (national/state/regional/town level) that internalises
environmental considerations into various sectors viz. housing, traffic &
transportation, industry etc. is lacking in the country. This has led to
unbalanced development, increased influx into cities and formation of
uneconomical agglomerations and ecologically degraded areas and
over-exploitation of resources.
The increasing public interest litigation (PIL) for relocating
environmentally incompatible land uses are indicative of the fact that the
decisions in respect of siting industrial and other projects will be
increasingly dictated by public opinion.
The environmental clearance by the regulatory authorities does not
necessarily imply zero pollution from an industry.
From the above
stated facts, it is evident that the major challenge is not just finding a site
for an industry or a developmental activity but is finding a solution for
achieving sustainable development. It is being increasingly realised that the
developmental activities are to be planned in such a way that the socio-economic
objectives are fulfilled without causing adverse impacts on the environment. The
constraints to be taken into account for working out a viable approach are as
follows:
In view of the existing social and living conditions, economic interests may
tend to over-ride the environmental aspects;
Ecosystem are already over-used in some areas;
Introduction of spatial planning which involves highly complex nature of
planning activities is a daunting task particularly in a large country, like
India;
Lack of legal framework for spatial planning, dearth of financial resources,
inadequate environmental awareness, shortage of manpower and limitations in
technical competence are among the constraints in integration of environmental
concerns in the development process.
In India, presently spatial
planning approach is mostly limited to urban areas. This has been leading to
unbalanced development and formation of uneconomic agglomerations on one hand
and depleted ecological areas on the other. Spatial planning based on assessment
of existing environmental profiles as well as potential assimilative capacity
could help environmentally acceptable development and resolve the conflicts
which are otherwise confronted with. Planning of activities based on assessment
of local or regional environmental impacts could be a useful approach for
introducing the concept of spatial planning in a limited manner under Indian
conditions.
The Central Pollution Control Board (CPCB) has taken
initiatives towards introduction of environmental (spatial) planning as a tool
for environmental protection. The present paper details the various activities
of CPCB under the environmental planning programme.
The
Programme Acceptance of the environmental planning programme initiated by
CPCB is growing fast. There is an increasing demand, to diversify the scope of
the studies for environmentally compatible land management beyond the siting of
industries. The programme has now been extended upto 2003 under the World
bank-funded 'Environment Management Capacity Building Programme'. The programme
has been widened and several environmental planning activities at various
levels, as below, have been taken up.
National Level
Environmental Atlas of India
(a compilation of environmental information presented in the
form of maps, text, statistics etc.)
Environmental Atlas for Metro
Cities (a depiction of trends of pollution for the metropolitan and other
major cities in the country)
State Level
Mapping of environmentally sensitive zones and industrial
sites - State wise
(provides information on environmentally sensitive zones such
as national parks, sanctuaries, forests etc. in the are map)
District Level
Zoning Atlas for Siting of Industries
(zones and classifies the environment, District-wise, and
provides information on environmentally sensitive zones and possible sites/zones
for siting of industries)
Local Level
Industrial Estate Planning
(these studies, in continuation of the Zoning Atlas studies,
help in identifying sites for industrial estates or growth centres or a cluster
of industries.)
Environmental Management Plan for Urban Areas
(studies are targeted at identifying problems due to poor land use compatibility
and lack of infrastructure in cities, and also to provide solutions. Planning
authorities form cities are also being trained on environmental considerations
in urban planning)
Other Activities
Training, workshops and awareness programmes for Govt.
bodies, NGOs, Industrial Associations etc. Environmental planning capacity
building in the State Pollution Control Boards Pilot studies, Research
Details, in brief, of various activities initiated by CPCB are given
below.
Environmental Atlas of India The Environmental Atlas of India is a
compilation of all the environmentally related information presented in the form
of maps and text including statistical data. This Atlas is scheduled to be
released during year 2000. The scale adopted is 1:12 million for general maps
and 1:2 million for detailed maps.
Environmental Atlas for Metro Cities
The objective of the
study on 'Environmental Atlas for Metro Cities' is to prepare an Environmental
Atlas for the metro and other major cities showing the pollution data and its
trends. The pollution data includes air quality, water quality, solid waste
generation and disposal and noise pollution. The Atlas is being prepared in the
scale of about 1:12 million (A3 size) and is scheduled to be released during
year 2000.
Mapping of Environmentally Sensitive Zones and Industrial Sites -
State-wise
This activity aims at presenting the information on
environmentally sensitive zones viz. national parks, reserved forests, protected
forests etc. and industrial sites, state-wise, in the form of maps. These maps
will prove to be a good data-base and will be highly useful in taking decisions
on industrial sites. The pilot study for Bihar taken up in 1996 has been
completed. During 1997-98, 11 States have been covered. Six more States were
taken up during 1998-99.
Zoning Atlas for Siting of Industries - District-wise
The Zoning
Atlas for Siting of Industries zones and classifies the environment in a
District and presents the pollution receiving potential of various sites/zones
in the District and the possible alternate sites for industries, through
easy-to-read maps. The industrial zones are identified based on the sensitivity
and pollution receiving potential of the District. In the pilot phase during
1995-96, Zoning Atlas for 19 Districts in 14 States were completed. In the
second phase during 1997-99 Zoning Atlas for 42 Districts were completed. About
50 priority Districts will be covered by 2001.
Industrial Estate Planning
As a continuation of the Zoning Atlas
study, the industrial estate planning studies are being taken up at a more
micro-level (scale 1:50,000 and lower) to finally come up with sites for
industrial estates. These studies will be highly useful to the State Government
Departments, such as the Industrial Departments responsible for industrial
development. Studies for fifteen sites will be completed by the year 2000.
Environmental Management Plan for Urban Areas
The urban
agglomerations in India are rapidly growing in terms of size, population and
developmental activities. There has been increasing trend of pollution and
thereby environmental impacts. Most of the impacts and risks can be reduced by
proper planning of various activities. During 1996, pilot studies were initiated
for preparation of environmental management plans for Kanpur Urban Area and the
Port Town of Haldia. These studies helped in developing guidelines for
conducting similar studies for other urban areas.
Training of
Planners The planning departments of cities and municipalities have a
crucial role in environmentally compatible land use management, which plays a
key role in achieving sustainable development. They, however, lack the needed
instruments and skills to incorporate the results of environmental plans into
urban planning. Environmentally compatible Masterplans and development plans
are, therefore, practically non-existent. As a consequence, environmental
conditions in many cities of India are rapidly deteriorating.
To bridge
the gap between environment and urban planning, a series of training programmes
are being conducted by CPCB for the planners from the Planning/Development
Authorities Conclusion CPCB had successfully completed
the work taken up in the first phase and second phase of the project. Initial
efforts were put in to develop methodologies, test them and refine them. Also,
efforts were put in to develop trained manpower and install the needed
facilities.
The budget is now available for the period 1997 to 2003.
Teams with qualified staff have been built at CPCB and at most SPCBs that are
participating in the programme. The needed facilities and equipment are already
installed at CPCB and are under installation at SPCBs. The needed
data/information is being collected through participatory role of various
resource organisations. An environmental database is being created with the
expert organisations. The expertise of foreign agencies within the country and
abroad is being utilised to produce high quality and reliable outputs in
relatively shorter time using the latest technology (remote sensing, GIS etc.).
Efforts are being put in to implement the results.
India is a vast
country and has diversified regions. The solutions developed at CPCB had inputs
from the German planning system, the pilot studies conducted for Pondicherry on
planned industrial development by CPCB, the pilot studies conducted for Hassan
District (Karnataka) by the Karnataka State Council for Science & Technology
and GTZ and the experience of the engineers and scientists of CPCB. The
environmental planning programme of CPCB includes many custom-made solutions.
The studies were transferable to all parts of the country with modifications.
Planned development is what everyone might like to have, but what has not been
done over several years cannot be done over night. The solutions and experiences
of CPCB could come handy for various organisations within the country.