Page 1 of 1
Territory Governance - Adding 3rd dimension

Caroline Tasse
Branch Manager of
Vectuel Middle East
Email: c.tasse@vectuel.com
The advantage of
3D in high definition
is its ability to
understand a city,
its areas, its
functioning and its
dynamics as they
are on the ground.
This article talks
about the power of
3D interactive in
decision-making
and in territory
governance
3D technology has evolved
over the years from being
purely a technical tool to a
multi-pronged tool for all the stakeholders
in the area of governance.
The main advantage of 3D in high
definition is its ability to understand
a city, its areas, its functioning and its
dynamics. A powerful tool for decision-
making, 3D interactive enables
a user to be fully aware of the impact
of a project in an existing environment.
3D technology is playing an increasing
role in territory management for
two reasons. The first one is the technological
availability of computers
(hardware) and software to ingest 3D
databases in high definition: which involves more data to
store and to visualise, better display capacities, more powerful
calculation tools, etc. The second reason is the diversification
and the increase of proven needs among the
stakeholders of territory governance. In the past 3D technology
was mainly used by engineers in the field of GIS.
Today, it has opened up to other requirements and needs
like architecture, communication, town planning, security,
Internet, GIS, design and transport. Among these, priority
is to serve urbanism and architecture
purposes and this requires
high definition data. We cannot create
the simulation of an architectural
building with low quality 3D environment
that provides poor rendering.
Thus 3D technology has incorporated
the management and updating of 3D
high definition database. CityGML,
an OGC standard, answered this
expectation by normalising levels of
modelling, from basic and external
modelling (boxes) to high detail and
inside modelling of buildings.
No software can meet all business
needs. So, it is essential to distinguish
the creation of data from its use and
to emphasise the interoperability of
this data in order for all territory
stakeholders to be able to work with
it. 3D modelling aims to open 3D
data not only to different businesses
but also to diverse interlocutors. Thus
3D interactive, also called virtual reality,
is a powerful tool for decisionmaking
and communication between
all players in the territory of governance,
as well as to the general public.
What is 3D data in high
definition?
Today, 3D technology represents different
realities interpreted by diverse
levels of details according the application.
CityGML has standardised
these levels of details. It is a common
information model for representing
3D urban projects enabling the storage
and exchange of virtual 3D city models.
The first level of details, called LoD0, refers to the modelling
of the relief (DTM) textured with true orthophotography.
It is used for display on visualisation tools such
as Google Earth. The second level of details LoD1 represents
the very basic shape of buildings, like a box or cube.
These data are used for technical calculations such as
wave propagation, aerodynamics, etc.
Realism becomes a part of 3D modelling from LoD2,
thanks to the modelling of the roof superstructures and to
the dressing of the facades with aerial imagery. With this,
a fly through gives low definition realism and 3D modelling
may be used as communication purposes such as on
Google Earth, for instance.

The two following levels, LoD3 and LoD4, keep increasing
the quality and the 3D definition of the modelling.
With LoD3, the facades are dressed with pictures taken
from the street and the details of the facades (balcony,
arch, etc. are modelled more finely.

LoD3 serves the
purposes of urbanism
and architecture for
analysis of the urban
environment at
paedestrian level and
for project simulation.
The level of realism
is incredibly astonishing
and enables
the export of data
into virtual reality.
Finally, LoD4 is the
inside modelling of
the building that
meets, for example,
security requirements.
The 3D data has
been enriched to
meet other requirements
of the stakeholders
of territory
management.
3D data interoperable and upgradable
The need of territory governance is to have diverse
and high definition data at the disposal of all stakeholders.
It is essential to differentiate 3D georeferenced
data from its uses. By creating 3D georeferenced database
in high definition (LoD3 andD4 data), architects,
town planner and external services provider have the
possibility to collect the data they need to work on a
project.
The 3D modelling in high definition is especially dedicated
to three core businesses of territory governance.
Firstly, urbanism/town planning and architecture will be
able to edit construction rules, to preserve the visibility
from and on the future projects, to simulate future developments
and assess their impacts in the existing environment,
etc. Secondly, GIS will have, at its disposal, more
detailed data for more specific calculations dedicated to
urban management and planning like assessment of the
efficacy of lighting systems, traffic simulation and sun
view for solar panels installation.
Finally, communication is a significant factor for the
success of territory management and planning. 3D technology
enables the visualisation of a project from different
angles. Various stakeholders, from general public to
investors and decision-makers, will be able to understand
and to be aware of the effects and impact of a project.
Strategic for decision-making and for explanation of the
development to all involved people, 3D interactive supports
projects through its promotion and communication
all around the world.
From 3D GIS models to virtual reality
The advantages of this technology are numerous. This is a
powerful tool enabling decision-makers to understand
and explain in 3D the large urbanism and architecture
projects, to analyse and validate a master plan, to assess
territory risks, to communicate about the city and to let
people discover it through Internet, to supply data to GIS
applications, to have at your disposal data relevant for civil
security, to create a urban database for consultancy of
developers, town planners, architects, etc.
Interactive 3D shows an architectural model at the same
time in its environment and from different view angles.
The two major benefits for architects and town planners
are to explain the projects and to take decisions. Virtual
reality prevents wrong interpretation and construction
mistakes by offering a unique view of the project which
the stakeholders can approve.