GISdevelopment.net ---> Proceedings ---> Map India ---> Map India 2000
© GISdevelopment.net. All rights reserved.
GIS application for Land Water Interface Production System and Flood Plain Zone Mapping
Dr. Nirupama and Prof. P.K. Sinha
Water and Land Management Institute (WALMI)
WALMI Bhawan, Utrathia, Lucknow - 226 006
Dr. Nirupama and Prof. P.K. Sinha
Water and Land Management Institute (WALMI)
WALMI Bhawan, Utrathia, Lucknow - 226 006
Abstract
An effort to understand the Interrelationships between competing commodity production systems on floodplains, which could be incorporated into management strategies, is the main purpose of this study. It is shown that with the help of Geographic Information System (GIS) a systems understanding, including environmental and socio-economic elements, of the resource base and resource use patterns in floodplain production systems can be developed to achieve the desired goal. Thereby, leading to "the development of systems management strategies for increased productivity, diversity of resource base, equitability and sustainability in floodplain systems".
Introduction
Natural resources are invaluable, therefore, should be used with utmost care and planning so as to fulfil the needs of ever increasing population in Asian countries. Natural hazards like floods occur year after year playing havoc to the mankind in terms of human life and property. Natural resources - mainly land and water, under Asian subcontinent condition, are endowed with rich diversity and vast expanse.
Rainwater runoff should be managed through watershed development and should also utilise the local resources especially labour. Sustainable development plans like widespread afforestation and erosion prevention will begin to be felt within a decade (Mishra, 1996). Long term continuity is a vital ingredient in the strategy for sustainable development. FAO has defined that the orientation of technological and institutional changes in such a manner as to ensure the attainment and continued satisfaction of human needs for present and future generation. Such sustainable development conserves land, water, plant and animal genetic resources, is environmentally non-degrading, technically appropriate, economically viable and socially acceptable.
The Overseas Development Institute (ODI) commissioned participatory watershed management studies in parts of India and inferred (Turton et al., 1998);
GIS allows extremely simple form of presentation of the existing facts and scenarios, which is very important for a sustainable participatory approach. Specialists and common man, alike, should get the feel of their surroundings, problems and remedies in the form of various options. We should be able to provide adequate and quick information to the policy makers and also should be able to make changes in suggested options fairly quickly. All this can be achieved with the help of GIS techniques.
Purpose
The project is aimed at the widespread developmental problem of small and marginal farmers' and fishers' needs being poorly addressed by interventions that fail to take account of the complex interactions in floodplain production systems. The consequence of this is that research and planning both have little positive impact for these primary producers, and due to poor understanding of the systems, may even have negative impacts. The ultimate result is that resource poor producers continue to face conditions of declining income and sustainability of livelihood.
Methodology and Approach
The socio-economic starting point has been a full census of the villages around the beel and selection of representative households across the whole spectrum of "wealth", which is determined according to land holding, validated by wealth ranking (Fig. 4). The output will be a detailed analysis of who is doing what, where and when, and why are they doing that rather than anything else.
This type of study structure will help identify over-exploited and under-used resources, i.e., areas of conflict and complementarily. Taking this approach will provide an understanding of the overlapping matrix of livelihood strategies and differential use of floodplain resources by different producer group. This can then be used to assess how actions such as using surface water for irrigation will affect various producer groups (fishermen, sharecroppers, large farmers, etc) and social groups. This analysis can also be used in participatory planning and management of floodplain resources, using mutual learning about different group's goals and strategies for floodplain resources to improve approaches such as co-management.
Conclusion
The study is both participatory and interdisciplinary. Integration of social science, soil science, agricultural science, fisheries, hydrology and GIS expertise is the key to the sustainable management and development. Much of the data, particularly in relation to terrestrial resources and terrestrial production, has a spatial dimension. GIS, using the Arc system, has been invaluable for exploring and presenting relationships such as those between flood depth and cropping pattern.
Out of total 4730 agricultural plots, constituting about 8.71 km2 area, in beel, about 2100 plots, constituting about 53% of the total area, get submerged in water destroying the cultivation and livelihood of the local farmers. This phenomenon takes place year after year forcing farmers to look for alternate cropping system and other livelihood means. While the flood depth in the larger affected area is about 0.25m in the monsoon months of July and August, the deeper areas towards the beel get more than 2m deep with beel at water level of 4m depth leaving no chance at all for any kind of cultivation.
A complete account of observations, inferences and suggestions will be come out at the completion of the work. To monitor the sustainability of the development and implementation of the study results, there should be a post-project observation period as well.
Acknowledgements
Authors are thankful to Dr. John W. Gowing and Mr. Julian J.F. Barr, chief scientists executing the project at the Centre for Land Use and Water Resources Research (CLUWRR), University of Newcastle, Newcastle upon Tyne, UK. The first author had worked with the team during her one-year post-doctoral stay with them.
References
Access for Windows 95, Microsoft Office 97 Professional, Users' Guide. Arcview GIS, The Geographic Information System for Everyone, Environmental Systems Research Institute, Inc, USA. Mishra, B., 1996, A successful case of participatory watershed management at Ralegan Siddhi village in district Ahmadnagar, Maharashtra, India. Turton, C., Warner, M. and Groom, B., 1998, Scaling up participatory watershed development in India: A review of the literature, Agricultural Research & Extension Network, Network paper no. 86.
An effort to understand the Interrelationships between competing commodity production systems on floodplains, which could be incorporated into management strategies, is the main purpose of this study. It is shown that with the help of Geographic Information System (GIS) a systems understanding, including environmental and socio-economic elements, of the resource base and resource use patterns in floodplain production systems can be developed to achieve the desired goal. Thereby, leading to "the development of systems management strategies for increased productivity, diversity of resource base, equitability and sustainability in floodplain systems".
Introduction
Natural resources are invaluable, therefore, should be used with utmost care and planning so as to fulfil the needs of ever increasing population in Asian countries. Natural hazards like floods occur year after year playing havoc to the mankind in terms of human life and property. Natural resources - mainly land and water, under Asian subcontinent condition, are endowed with rich diversity and vast expanse.
Rainwater runoff should be managed through watershed development and should also utilise the local resources especially labour. Sustainable development plans like widespread afforestation and erosion prevention will begin to be felt within a decade (Mishra, 1996). Long term continuity is a vital ingredient in the strategy for sustainable development. FAO has defined that the orientation of technological and institutional changes in such a manner as to ensure the attainment and continued satisfaction of human needs for present and future generation. Such sustainable development conserves land, water, plant and animal genetic resources, is environmentally non-degrading, technically appropriate, economically viable and socially acceptable.
The Overseas Development Institute (ODI) commissioned participatory watershed management studies in parts of India and inferred (Turton et al., 1998);
- Results from one success story are not easily replicable;
- Approaches to development are resource intensive;
- There is uncertainty over the long-term institutional and ecological sustainability of modified system.
GIS allows extremely simple form of presentation of the existing facts and scenarios, which is very important for a sustainable participatory approach. Specialists and common man, alike, should get the feel of their surroundings, problems and remedies in the form of various options. We should be able to provide adequate and quick information to the policy makers and also should be able to make changes in suggested options fairly quickly. All this can be achieved with the help of GIS techniques.
Purpose
The project is aimed at the widespread developmental problem of small and marginal farmers' and fishers' needs being poorly addressed by interventions that fail to take account of the complex interactions in floodplain production systems. The consequence of this is that research and planning both have little positive impact for these primary producers, and due to poor understanding of the systems, may even have negative impacts. The ultimate result is that resource poor producers continue to face conditions of declining income and sustainability of livelihood.
Methodology and Approach
- Formal quantitative survey, including detailed soil survey, water resources audit, crop pattern monitoring and fishing effort monitoring.
- Parallel participatory survey with farmers and fishers to understand how they perceive their environment.
- Field monitoring plus modelling relationships between farming, fishing, homestead and other activities according to such factors as season, flood depth, socio-economic category, access to labour, access to land, access to common property water bodies.
- The modelling tools should include :
- ARC/INFO and ARCVIEW GIS software
- ACCESS Relational Database
- QSR NUD*IST qualitative data analysis
- Formulate and evaluate more sustainable and equitable strategies for floodplain management, which will be achieved by involving participatory experimental work to test and develop sustainable resource management options. These will address constraints identified during an earlier project and during the on-going studies. The resource users will appraise options.
- The above flow chart (Fig. 1) explains the methodology for this kind of approach. Although the survey and monitoring is to be done for the entire region by selecting sample plots, at present only one portion has been completed, which has been presented in this paper.
Fig.1 Flow chart describing the approach to the study
The socio-economic starting point has been a full census of the villages around the beel and selection of representative households across the whole spectrum of "wealth", which is determined according to land holding, validated by wealth ranking (Fig. 4). The output will be a detailed analysis of who is doing what, where and when, and why are they doing that rather than anything else.
This type of study structure will help identify over-exploited and under-used resources, i.e., areas of conflict and complementarily. Taking this approach will provide an understanding of the overlapping matrix of livelihood strategies and differential use of floodplain resources by different producer group. This can then be used to assess how actions such as using surface water for irrigation will affect various producer groups (fishermen, sharecroppers, large farmers, etc) and social groups. This analysis can also be used in participatory planning and management of floodplain resources, using mutual learning about different group's goals and strategies for floodplain resources to improve approaches such as co-management.
Conclusion
The study is both participatory and interdisciplinary. Integration of social science, soil science, agricultural science, fisheries, hydrology and GIS expertise is the key to the sustainable management and development. Much of the data, particularly in relation to terrestrial resources and terrestrial production, has a spatial dimension. GIS, using the Arc system, has been invaluable for exploring and presenting relationships such as those between flood depth and cropping pattern.
Out of total 4730 agricultural plots, constituting about 8.71 km2 area, in beel, about 2100 plots, constituting about 53% of the total area, get submerged in water destroying the cultivation and livelihood of the local farmers. This phenomenon takes place year after year forcing farmers to look for alternate cropping system and other livelihood means. While the flood depth in the larger affected area is about 0.25m in the monsoon months of July and August, the deeper areas towards the beel get more than 2m deep with beel at water level of 4m depth leaving no chance at all for any kind of cultivation.
A complete account of observations, inferences and suggestions will be come out at the completion of the work. To monitor the sustainability of the development and implementation of the study results, there should be a post-project observation period as well.
Acknowledgements
Authors are thankful to Dr. John W. Gowing and Mr. Julian J.F. Barr, chief scientists executing the project at the Centre for Land Use and Water Resources Research (CLUWRR), University of Newcastle, Newcastle upon Tyne, UK. The first author had worked with the team during her one-year post-doctoral stay with them.
References
Access for Windows 95, Microsoft Office 97 Professional, Users' Guide. Arcview GIS, The Geographic Information System for Everyone, Environmental Systems Research Institute, Inc, USA. Mishra, B., 1996, A successful case of participatory watershed management at Ralegan Siddhi village in district Ahmadnagar, Maharashtra, India. Turton, C., Warner, M. and Groom, B., 1998, Scaling up participatory watershed development in India: A review of the literature, Agricultural Research & Extension Network, Network paper no. 86.